Does it arrive?
Delivery, bounces, greylisting, ESP events.
Audit type · PSA
A phishing simulation audit measures the defensive chain, not the people in it. One bait, up to three variants, one named mailbox. Every result is a measurement with a header line behind it — never a judgement about a colleague.
Delivery, bounces, greylisting, ESP events.
Inbox, spam, category tab or quarantine — read from the mailbox, not guessed.
SPF, DKIM, DMARC alignment and the gateway verdict, taken from the received headers.
Link rewriting, warning interstitial, block page or nothing at all.
| ID | Class | What it proves |
|---|---|---|
| V1 | Authenticated brand lure | Whether content filtering catches a technically valid message |
| V2 | Forged sender | Whether the domain policy (DMARC) is actually enforced |
| V3 | Cousin domain / display name | Whether lookalike senders and reply-to mismatches are seen |
V4–V6 (internal sender, thread hijack, QR lure) require separate approval because they touch staff or devices.
| ID | Measurement | Source |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | Delivery | ESP event or SMTP 250 |
| M2 | Mailbox placement | labelIds / InferenceClassification |
| M3–M5 | SPF, DKIM, DMARC result | Authentication-Results, Received-SPF |
| M6 | Link handling | Original HTML vs. delivered HTML |
| M7 | Click | Landing page event, no input captured |
| M8 | Reporting | Qualitative, only if a process exists |
Fixed weights so campaigns stay comparable: authentication 30 · mailbox placement 25 · filter verdict 20 · link handling 15 · human response 10. Placement is scored in the correct direction per variant — inbox is right for a valid message, spam is right for a forgery.
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 85–100 | The chain holds; remaining risk sits with the human |
| 70–84 | Technically solid, gaps in link protection or DMARC |
| 50–69 | At least one layer is ineffective |
| below 50 | Phishing is deliverable today and it works |
A simulation is only legitimate on domains the client owns and mailboxes the client named. Remediation and hardening are a separate, commissioned engagement — the audit shows the exposure, not the cure.